Resources

Imagine walking through a busy city street when suddenly, a car strikes a pedestrian. Instinctively, many assume the driver is always at fault for the accident. However, determining fault in pedestrian accidents is often more complicated. While drivers have a duty of care to yield to pedestrians, there are instances where a pedestrian may also share fault for the accident.

This article explores whether a driver is always at fault when a pedestrian is hit, how fault is determined in pedestrian-car accident cases, and what injured pedestrians and motorists should know about their legal rights. If you or someone you know has been involved in a pedestrian accident, consulting an experienced personal injury lawyer can be crucial in understanding liability and securing rightful compensation.

Understanding Fault in Pedestrian Accidents

Determining fault in a pedestrian accident case requires a careful examination of the circumstances surrounding the collision. In many cases, drivers are expected to yield to pedestrians at marked crosswalks and intersections. However, pedestrians must also adhere to traffic laws to ensure their safety.

1. The Role of Negligence – Fault for a pedestrian accident is often determined by negligence. Negligence occurs when a driver or pedestrian fails to exercise reasonable care, leading to an accident. A motorist may be found at fault if they were speeding, distracted, or failed to yield to a pedestrian at a crosswalk. However, if a pedestrian is at fault, such as by jaywalking or walking into traffic unexpectedly, they may share fault for the accident.

2. Comparative Negligence in Pedestrian-Car Accidents – Some states follow a comparative negligence rule, where fault in a pedestrian accident is divided between the driver and pedestrian. For example, if a pedestrian was jaywalking but the driver was speeding, both parties could be assigned a percentage of fault. If a pedestrian is found 30 percent at fault, their compensation may be reduced by that percentage in an accident claim.

3. Legal Duty of Care for Drivers and Pedestrians – A vehicle driver must exercise caution when approaching crosswalks, school zones, and areas with heavy pedestrian traffic. However, pedestrians also have responsibilities. Pedestrians must obey traffic signals, use designated crossings, and avoid reckless behavior that could contribute to the accident. If a pedestrian is found to have caused the accident, their ability to file a personal injury claim may be impacted.
   

Common Causes of Pedestrian Accidents and Liability

Car accidents involving pedestrians occur due to a variety of reasons. Some of the most common causes include driver negligence, pedestrian misjudgment, or a combination of both.

1. Driver Negligence – A driver may be found at fault for a pedestrian accident due to:
   • Distracted driving (texting, talking on the phone, or adjusting in-car systems)
     
   • Speeding, reckless driving, or failing to yield to pedestrians
     
   • Running a red light or stop sign, striking a pedestrian crossing legally

2. Pedestrian Fault in an Accident – While pedestrians are often assumed to be the victims, they can be at fault in pedestrian accidents. Common scenarios include:
   • Jaywalking or crossing outside of designated crosswalks
     
   • Walking while distracted, such as texting or wearing headphones
     
   • Running into the street without checking for oncoming traffic

3. Accidents Involving Pedestrians in Shared Fault Cases – In some cases, both parties contributed to the accident. If a pedestrian crossed against a traffic signal while a driver was speeding, liability may be shared. Car insurance companies and courts will examine the accident case to determine the degree of fault assigned to each party.
   

Legal Options for Injured Pedestrians and Drivers

If a pedestrian is hit by a car, it is important to take immediate action to ensure legal protection and proper medical treatment. Whether the pedestrian or driver is at fault for the accident, the steps taken after the accident can impact the outcome of an accident claim.

1. Steps for Injured Pedestrians
   

   • Seek medical attention immediately, even if injuries appear minor.
     
   • Document the accident scene, taking photos of traffic signals, crosswalks, and vehicle damage.
     
   • Contact an accident attorney to determine fault and liability in the pedestrian accident case.
     

2. How Drivers Can Protect Themselves in an Accident Case
   

   • Avoid admitting fault at the time of the accident.
     
   • Gather evidence, such as eyewitness accounts and surveillance footage.
     
   • Contact a car accident lawyer if there are disputes over fault in the pedestrian accident.
     

3. The Role of Insurance Companies in Pedestrian Accidents
   

   • Car insurance companies will assess the degree of fault and determine compensation.
     
   • If a pedestrian is found partially at fault, their accident claim may be reduced based on comparative negligence laws.
     
   • A pedestrian accident attorney can negotiate with insurers to ensure fair compensation for medical bills, pain and suffering, and lost wages.
     

Conclusion

Pedestrian accidents are complex, and determining fault requires a thorough investigation. While many assume a driver is always at fault, pedestrian behavior plays a critical role in assessing liability. If you or a loved one has been injured in a pedestrian-car accident, seeking legal guidance from a personal injury lawyer can help protect your rights. Understanding traffic laws, the duty of care, and how insurance companies evaluate fault can make a significant difference in accident claims.

FAQs

Are drivers always at fault when a pedestrian is hit?

No, drivers are not always at fault in pedestrian accidents. Fault is determined based on negligence, traffic laws, and whether the pedestrian contributed to the accident.

Can a pedestrian be at fault in a pedestrian-car accident?

Yes, a pedestrian can be at fault if they jaywalk, ignore traffic signals, or act recklessly, such as running into traffic.

What should I do if I’m hit by a car as a pedestrian?

Seek medical attention immediately, document the accident scene, gather witness statements, and consult a pedestrian accident attorney for legal guidance.

How do insurance companies determine fault in pedestrian accidents?

Insurance companies assess traffic laws, accident reports, and witness statements to assign a percentage of fault in a pedestrian accident case.

Do I need a personal injury lawyer after a pedestrian accident?

If you’ve been injured in a pedestrian accident, hiring a personal injury lawyer can help you navigate legal complexities, determine fault, and maximize your compensation.

 

The information provided on this blog is for general informational purposes only. All information on the site is provided in good faith; however, we make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information on the site. Under no circumstance shall we have any liability to you for any loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of the use of the site or reliance on any information provided on the site. Your use of the site and your reliance on any information on the site are solely at your own risk. This blog is not intended to be a substitute for professional legal advice. Always seek the advice of an attorney or other qualified legal provider with any questions you may have regarding a legal matter.